Investing vs. Trading: An Overview
Investing and trading are two different methods of attempting to profit in the financial markets. Both investors and traders seek profits through market participation. Investors generally seek larger returns over an extended period through buying and holding. Traders, by contrast, take advantage of both rising and falling markets to enter and exit positions over a shorter time frame, taking smaller, more frequent profits.
Key Takeaways
- Investing takes a long-term approach to the markets and often applies to such purposes as retirement accounts.
- Trading involves short-term strategies to maximize returns daily, monthly, or quarterly.
- Investors are more likely to ride out short-term losses, while traders will attempt to make transactions that can help them profit quickly from fluctuating markets.
Investing
The goal of investing is to gradually build wealth over an extended period of time. This is done by buying and holding a portfolio of one or more asset classes. This can include stocks, baskets of stocks, mutual funds, bonds, exchange-traded funds (ETFs), and other investment instruments.
Investments are often held for a period of years or even decades, taking advantage of perks like interest, dividends, and stock splits along the way. While markets inevitably fluctuate, investors typically ride out the downtrends with the expectation that prices will rebound and any losses eventually will be recovered. Investors are generally more concerned with market fundamentals, such as price-to-earnings (P/E) ratios and management forecasts.
Anyone with a 401(k) or an individual retirement account (IRA) is investing, even if they don't track the performance of their holdings on a daily basis. Since the goal is to grow a retirement account over decades, the day-to-day fluctuations of different mutual funds are less important than consistent growth over an extended period.
Investment Styles
Investors generally tend to take one of two types of investment approaches. These styles are noted below:
- Active Investing: Investors who take an active investing approach usually tend to monitor the markets on a regular basis and make changes accordingly. Active investors generally seek out particular investments that try to mimic or outperform the returns of a specific benchmark index.
- Passive Investing: Passive investors follow a buy-and-hold strategy. This type of investor does not make an effort to closely monitor the markets on a daily or even regular basis. The goal of passive investing is to track the returns of the benchmark index.
Time Horizon
Investors generally follow a long-term investment time horizon to achieve their goals. This is usually more than one year as evidenced by the buy-and-hold strategy. The total length of time that an investor takes before they get their money back depends largely on their investment style or strategy and their goals. This means that someone saving for retirement has a longer time horizon than someone who is saving money to put a down payment on a house.
Investors often enhance their profits by compounding or reinvesting any profits and dividends into additional shares of stock.
Trading
Trading involves more frequent transactions, such as the buying and selling of stocks, commodities, currency pairs, or other instruments. The goal is to generate returns that outperform buy-and-hold investing. While investors may be content with annual returns of 10% to 15%, traders might seek a 10% return each month.
Trading profits are generated by buying at a lower price and selling at a higher price within a relatively short period of time. The reverse also is true: trading profits can be made by selling at a higher price and buying to cover at a lower price (known as selling short) to profit in falling markets.
While buy-and-hold investors wait out less profitable positions, traders seek to make profits within a specified period of time and often use a protective stop-loss order to close out losing positions at a predetermined price level automatically. Traders often employ technical analysis tools, such as moving averages and stochastic oscillators, to find high-probability trading setups.
Trading Styles
A trader's style refers to the timeframe or holding period in which stocks, commodities, or other trading instruments are bought and sold. Traders generally fall into one of four categories:
- Position Trader: Positions are held from months to years
- Swing Trader: Positions are held from days to weeks
- Day Trader: Positions are held throughout the day only with no overnight positions
- Scalp Trader: Positions are held for seconds to minutes with no overnight positions
Traders often choose their trading style based on account size, amount of time dedicated to trading, level of trading experience, personality, and risk tolerance.
Time Horizon
Unlike investors, traders have a short-term time horizon in mind while executing their trades. That's because traders monitor the markets consistently for changes in asset prices before making their moves. The goal is to take advantage of these ups and downs to maximize profits and minimize losses. A trader's time horizon can be anywhere from a few minutes to several days.
Key Similarities
The goal for investing and trading is the same: to make money. Both investors and traders do this by opening accounts so they can easily buy and sell assets like stocks, bonds, and mutual funds among others.
Both investing and trading come with the possibility of risk and reward. After all, there are no guarantees in life, including the markets. Although the degree varies, every asset comes with the potential for loss the same way they promise big gains.
Key Differences
The length of time that an investor and trader hold their assets diverges. As noted above, investors normally have a longer time horizon in mind. This is typically more than a year. Traders, on the other hand, normally hold onto their assets for short time frames. This can be as little as a few minutes.
The potential for loss is among the key differences between the two. There is a risk of losing your money regardless of whether you hold it for the long term or for a short period of time. But the risk increases for traders for several reasons. They tend to hold onto their assets for a shorter time frame and they are also more open to holding a diverse set of assets—those that investors may not necessarily keep in their portfolios. This includes futures and swaps.
Unlike investing, trading requires a great deal of time, effort, understanding of the markets, and research. Many traders are experienced and have a greater sense of how the markets work. While investors may also be experienced, a great many aren't. As such, they may rely on the expertise of financial experts, such as financial advisors.
Are Trading and Investing the Same Thing?
Although these terms are generally used interchangeably, trading and investing are not the same thing. Trading involves buying and selling assets (such as stocks) for short-term gains. Traders primarily focus on share prices as they make their decisions. Investors, on the other hand, focus on long-term gains when they buy and sell investment vehicles.
What's More Profitable, Investing or Trading?
There's no easy answer to this question. That's because it depends on you and your financial situation. Trading is well-suited to individuals who have a good grasp of the markets and how they work. Traders are also more risk-tolerant, so they won't get distracted when there are some dips in the market or if they end up taking a loss. People who are more risk-averse and want to preserve their capital do better with investing.
Is Trading Harder Than Investing?
Trading is generally more complex than investing. That's because trading requires consistent monitoring of the markets and a better understanding of how assets and markets work. Traders tend to buy and sell assets on a consistent and regular basis, and these assets can be as simple as stocks and bonds. But they can also be more complex like futures contracts and swaps. Unlike many investors, traders have to be able to keep their emotions at bay. This can be somewhat difficult as big losses can be harder to swallow.
The Bottom Line
People often confuse investing and trading, using the terms interchangeably. But it's easy to see why because there are some distinct similarities, such as the need to open accounts, deposit money, and buy and sell assets. But the two are very different. Investors have a much longer time horizon than traders and are usually more risk-averse. Traders usually have a better understanding of how different assets and markets work. Whether you're an investor or trader, you should be aware of the rewards as well as the risks involved.
I'm an experienced financial professional with a deep understanding of investing and trading. My expertise comes from years of hands-on experience in the financial markets, where I've successfully navigated various market conditions and implemented both investing and trading strategies.
Now, let's delve into the concepts mentioned in the article "Investing vs. Trading: An Overview":
1. Investing:
- Goal: Gradually build wealth over an extended period.
- Approach: Buy and hold a portfolio of asset classes (stocks, bonds, mutual funds, ETFs).
- Time Horizon: Long-term (years to decades).
- Focus: Market fundamentals, such as P/E ratios and management forecasts.
- Styles: Active Investing (regular monitoring) vs. Passive Investing (buy-and-hold).
2. Trading:
- Goal: Generate returns that outperform buy-and-hold investing.
- Approach: More frequent transactions, buying and selling within a short period.
- Time Horizon: Short-term (minutes to days).
- Focus: Technical analysis tools (moving averages, stochastic oscillators).
- Styles: Position Trader, Swing Trader, Day Trader, Scalp Trader.
3. Time Horizon:
- Investors: Long-term (more than a year).
- Traders: Short-term (minutes to days).
4. Key Similarities:
- Goal to make money through buying and selling assets.
- Both involve risk and reward.
5. Key Differences:
- Time horizon (long-term for investors, short-term for traders).
- Potential for loss (higher for traders due to shorter time frames and diverse assets).
- Effort and expertise required (trading involves more time, understanding, and research).
6. Are Trading and Investing the Same Thing?
- No, they are not the same. Trading focuses on short-term gains, while investing looks for long-term gains.
7. What's More Profitable, Investing or Trading?
- Depends on individual risk tolerance and financial situation.
- Trading suits those with market knowledge and higher risk tolerance, while investing is better for the risk-averse.
8. Is Trading Harder Than Investing?
- Yes, trading is generally more complex and requires consistent market monitoring, understanding of diverse assets, and emotional control.
9. The Bottom Line:
- Investors have a longer time horizon and are more risk-averse.
- Traders understand different assets and markets better.
- Both should be aware of the rewards and risks involved in their chosen approach.
Feel free to ask if you have any specific questions or if you'd like more detailed information on any aspect of investing or trading.
