Swing Trader Review: Is IBD Performance Worth it? (2024)

Our editorial team uses a strict editorial review process to compile all reviews, research, and evaluations of any kind. Our company, WallStreetZen Limited, is supported by our user community and may receive a small commission when purchases are made through partner links. Commissions do not affect the opinions or evaluations of our editorial team.

Investor’s Business Daily claimed to create a tool that could help new swing traders beat the market. Since 90% of new swing traders fail to make a profit, that claim sparked a lot of interest…

But, do they actually deliver? Is IBD SwingTrader worth it?

I decided to answer those questions, and more, in this thorough Swing Trader review.

Stick around to learn what IBD SwingTrader is, how it operates, if it delivers, and if not, what alternatives are out there to help you swing trade with confidence.

The Bottom Line: Is IBD SwingTraderWorth It in 2024?

IBD SwingTraderis the brainchild of Investor’s Business Daily, a company that provides a curated list of stocks, complete with trade plans, alerts, and annotated charts through a simplified beginner-friendly platform for swing traders.

However, as you can see below, there’s some stiff competition out there in the market that may have more to offer to investors with more flexible time horizons, including Motley Fool Stock Advisor, Seeking Alpha, and WallStreetZen Premium. We’ll dig deeper into these alternatives later on in this Swing Trader review.

Swing Trader Review

Rating: 3.5/5

IBD Swing Trader Review: What are Customers Saying?

Unfortunately, most customers left a Swing Trader review that veered towards disappointment, expressing their dissatisfaction with its lackluster performance results, especially when compared to the S&P 500, which it consistently trailed.

Negative IBD Swing Trader reviews aside, the platform seems to shine as a simplified, easy-to-use platform with robust educational resources.

What is IBD SwingTrader?

IBD SwingTrader was developed by the renowned finance publication, Investor’s Business Daily. They designed it to take the complex world of swing trading and distill it down to a simplified process fit for beginners.

They provide basic swing trading educational resources and services, including 1:1 coaching calls, something that is rare in this industry. They also give stock picks along with recommended trade schedules and alerts.

How Does SwingTrader Work?

IBD SwingTrader curates a list of stock picks. Each pick comes with a trade plan, alerts, and easy-to-read charts.

The company targets gains within 5-10%. Trades typically last for around 3-10 days with stop losses set at 3-5% below the entry point.

Their claim to fame is that they follow the CAN SLIM® Investing System, a systematic approach to using criteria to find potential stocks that uses a combination of fundamental and technical analysis infused with momentum investing principles.

SwingTrader Features

• Access to Long and Short Trades
• Trade Setup for Every Trade, Including Buy Zone, Profit Goal, and Stop Loss
• Detailed Charts With Buy and Sell Points Clearly Marked on Each Chart
• Push Notifications and Email Alerts That Link Directly To Trading Ideas
• Live Quotes
• Easy Swipe Functionality For Quick Stock Idea Browsing
• Access to Past Trades and Chart Notes
• IBD’s Market Analysis Customized for a Swing Trading Environment
• Can Slim® Investing System Specially Curated by Long Time, Successful Investor and IBD® Founder William O’Neil
• Access To Scorecard, a Market Masters Monthly Virtual Meetup
• Quick Access to Free Coaching & Support Calls
• Curated Stock Recommendations
• Trade Management Tools
• Real-Time Alerts
• Educational Resources

IBD Swing Trader Performance

Regrettably, the IBD Swing Trader performance has been inconsistent — this remains a complaint in many a Swing Trader review.

• In 2020, the platform averaged 1.2% profit per trade; over 40% of trades closed at a loss.
• In the first half of 2021, IBD SwingTrader returned 11.7% — better than the year before, but lacking compared to the S&P 500’s 17.0% performance.

The company aims for profits around5-10%— well below the S&P 500’s 11.8% historical returns. The only benefit to this I can think of is SwingTrader is a learning tool for those trying to break into the world of swing trading.

Roughly 90% of swing traders stop trading in their first year, making very little, and often losing money. If you could learn how to swing trade with relative ease — while earning steady returns of 7%-10%, I can see why that might be appealing.

In fact, I am surprised that they do not highlight that in their marketing. I feel doing so might mitigate some of the negative IBD Swing Trader reviews out there.

SwingTrader Pricing

IBD SwingTrader offers two transparent pricing plans and an optional trial period.

• 5-Week Trial: $50
• Monthly: $69/month
• Annual: $699/year

SwingTrader Customer Service

The platform really shines with its customer support. In fact, that is noted repeatedly in most Swing Trader reviews.

They offer regular webinars and customer coaching support via phone and email, something that is very rare in this industry, and often only provided with expensive pro plans.

Some people will hire experts to make trades for them, but those services rarely come with coaching support and usually have high commissions.

Is SwingTrader Legit?

Yes. IBD SwingTraderis a 100% legitimate trading platform developed by a reputable company.

What raises eyebrows among potential users is the IBD Swing Trader performance and data analysis rarely align with their projection timeline, negating the effectiveness of their alerts and trading plans.

SwingTrader Vs. the Competition…

Earlier, I shared a chart comparing SwingTrader and some of its competitors. Let’s dig a little deeper:

SwingTrader Vs. Motley Fool Stock Advisor

Motley Fool Stock Advisoris a premium stock recommendation service offered by The Motley Fool, a highly respected financial and investment advisory company.

Though it does not specifically cater to swing traders, the company offers expert advice backed by extensive research, transparency, and a long-term investment approach.

Many investors opt to use them, including some swing traders, but they gear their recommendations to stocks you want to hold for a longer period.

Usability

The Motley Fool is celebrated for its ease of use, educational content, in-depth analysis, and spot-on advice on various stocks and investment themes. Since their recommendations can be trusted to perform close to expectation, they really save investors time on research and analysis.

Features

They offer comprehensive educational resources, including articles, videos, and podcasts, to build a strong investing foundation. Its supportive community allows you to interact, ask questions, and learn from others’ experiences.

Their stock picks are more long-term, high-quality stocks, and come with easy-to-follow analysis.

Comparison

In contrast, SwingTrader focuses on short-term trades typically more appealing for swing traders.

Though the platform offers coaching calls and meetups, it doesn’t seem IBD SwingTrader offers the same caliber of educational resources as the Motley Fool Stock Advisor since SwingTrader focuses on a lot of the basics.

While the IBD SwingTrader performance has been inconsistent, Motley Fool Stock Advisor boasts a solid track record of outperforming the market, with its average stock pick returning over 500% since 2002.

Head-to-Head: SwingTrader Vs. Motley Fool Stock Advisor

The Verdict?

SwingTrader is best for beginners looking for a simple platform to get started with swing trading.

Simplifying things, especially in the beginning, can really help with things like decision paralysis, so if you are new to swing trading and this is a typical problem for you, definitely consider SwingTrader.

Motley Fool Stock Advisoris best for long-term investors and swing traders willing to hold onto stocks longer term. It’s great for those seeking well-researched, accurate stock picks with growth potential.

SwingTrader Vs. Seeking Alpha

Seeking Alphais a comprehensive financial market analysis platform that offers investors access to a vast library of expertly curated content, including research articles, earnings call transcripts, and stock ratings, as well as a suite of portfolio management tools.

Usability

Seeking Alpha stands out with its crowdsourced approach, providing access to numerous vetted opinions and insights for all investment levels.

The comprehensive nature of the platform may feel like a lot for beginners, but their consistent performance makes their recommendations reliable, which is ideal for an investor of any experience.

Features

They offer a wide range of analysis tools, including fundamental and technical analysis, as well as various metrics and indicators. Its comprehensive portfolio tracking feature allows users to monitor investments and receive relevant news and analysis.

They also have helpful features such as stock screeners, Strong Buy stock picks, relevant market updates, and more.

Comparison

SwingTrader is a beginner-friendly platform focused on curated, swing trading opportunities, while Seeking Alpha offers a more comprehensive and diverse approach to investing.

The educational content quality of Seeking Alphasurpasses that of IBD SwingTrader’s more fundamental and basic knowledge base.

Performance-wise, SwingTrader pales next to Seeking Alpha, whose back-tested strategy has consistently outperformed the S&P 500 12 years in a row.

Head to Head: SwingTrader Vs. Seeking Alpha

The Verdict?

SwingTrader is best for beginnerslooking for a way to get started with swing trading while lowering risk and earning losses.

Seeking Alphais best for investors seeking a wide range of investment ideas backed by thorough research and analysis.

SwingTrader Vs. WallStreetZen Premium

WallStreetZen is an innovative platform designed to empower investors by providing them with insightful financial data and easy-to-understand analytics.

Using the latest technology to create user-friendly tools such as the Advanced Stock Screener, the platform offers stock comparison tools, in-depth financial analysis, expert-curated content, and more.

Usability

WallStreetZen has an intuitive interface and focuses on the modern investor, something that many platforms forget about.

Instead of narrowly focusing on outdated investing practices that might be better suited for institutions or those with an unusually large income, they provide tailored advice to investors who may not be experts in the industry, are busy with other priorities, and have a somewhat limited budget.

As a result, their recommendations use everyday terminology, are easy to follow, make sense for most budgets, and have your goals in mind.

Features

WallStreetZen Premium includes unlimited access to Zen Scores, their stock evaluator, stock and market forecasts, recommendations from top-performing analysts, enhanced stock screener tools with customizable filters, and a sleek and user-friendly platform.

Comparison

Though both platforms focus on educating investors, ultimately, IBD SwingTraderand WallStreetZen Premiumare two distinct investment platforms, with WallStreetZen concentrating on fundamental analysis and SwingTrader targeting swing trading strategies.

Using a specific stock analyst performance methodologyWallStreetZen was able to beat the S&P 500 98.4% of the time, while SwingTrader consistently trailed it.

Head to Head: SwingTrader Vs. WallStreetZen Premium

The Verdict?

SwingTrader is best for beginnerslooking for a way to have their hand held through their first year or so of swing trading while limiting their losses.

WallStreetZen Premiumis best for investors looking for data-driven insightsand easy-to-use, advanced research tools.

Is A Good Swing Trade Platform All You Need?

Short answer: Probably not.

Swing trading is a more advanced form of trading than long-term trading. Since you turn over a stock quicker than once every 1-5 years, swing trading is fast pace, requires more time analyzing, and has more opportunities to lose (and make) money.

That said, it really is a good idea to get a solid foundation under you. The good news is, you don’t have to go back to university to learn the basics of investing.

In fact, you can finish the Complete Foundation Stock Trading Courseby Udemy in as little as 9 hours.

Taught by Mohsen Hassan, a highly experienced trader and the founder of Bloom Trading, there is a lot to learn in the short course, including how the stock market works, the difference between exchanges, trading psychology, and more.

After that, you will want to learn, at a minimum, the best swing trading indicatorsas well as the best timeframe for swing tradingto really succeed in this endeavor.

Final Word: Swing Trader Review

IBD SwingTrader proves itself as a beginner-friendly platform. Their curated list of stocks, trade plans, trade alerts, and easy-to-read charts are definitely designed to make new swing traders’ lives easier.

But, my Swing Trader review would be negligent if it did not hold stock to its inconsistent historical performance.

Again, the platform performs better than 90% of swing traders getting started — something that should not be ignored for those wanting to branch into the world of swing trading — but it appears most traders will quickly outgrow the platform, at least if you want to improve your stock performance.

If you’re seeking better returns and more comprehensive research tools, explore alternative platforms, such as Motley Fool Stock Advisor,Seeking Alpha, or WallStreetZen Premium.

• Share
• Share
• Tweet